Journal of Plant Biotechnology : eISSN 2384-1397 / pISSN 1229-2818

Table. 3.

Table. 3.

Examples of published overseas comparative compositional studies with transgenic crops

Host plant Trait Parameter tested Counterpart Reference Location Year Statistical analysis Reference
Rice Herbicide tolerance (bar) AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, Bengal 14 1998/ 1999 TOST Xin et al. (2005)
Rice High iron (FERRITIN) AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, VI IR18644 - t-Test Gayen et al. (2013)
Rice ß-Carotene GR2E AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, TrPI, VI, CA PSBRc82 - 4 2015/ 2016 Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Swamy et al. (2019)
Cotton Herbicide tolerance (2,4-D/glyphocinate) DAS-81910-7 AA, FA, MI, PX, DA, MA, SA, G Isoline 6 (3 per each site) 8 - Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Herman et al. (2013)
Soybean Herbicide tolerance (2,4-D) DAS-68416-4 AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, VI, TI, R, S, I, L Maverick 6 (3 per each site) 8 2009 Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Herman et al. (2011)
Soybean γ-Linolenic acid enhanced AA, FA, PX, L, TrPI Pudou-8808 - 1 One-way ANOVA Qin et al. (2011)
Soybean Herbicide tolerance (glyphosate) 40-3-2 AA, FA, PX, I, PA, R, S, L Dekabig 11 (4 per each site) 5 2005 TI, Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Harrigan et al. (2007)
Soybean Herbicide tolerance Mon87708×Mon89788 AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, IS, L, R, S, TrPI, VI A3525 20/13 4 or 3 per each site 8 2008/ 2009 Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Taylor et al. (2017)
Maize Insect resistance (Cry34Ab1, Cry35Ab1) DAS-59122-7 AA, FA, PX, VI, PA, TrPI, R, FeA, I, CA Isoline - 8 2003/ 2004 t-test, Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Herman et al. (2007)
Maize Herbicide tolerance DAS-40278-9 AA, FA, MI, PX, VI, FeA, R, CA, I, TrPI Isoline 6 (3 per each site) 10 2009 Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Herman et al. (2010)
Maize Drought tolerance Mon87460 AA, FA, MI, PA, PX, VI, FeA, R, CA, TrPI Control 18 (3 per each site) 6 2006 TI, Mixed-model ANOVA Harrigan et al. (2009)
Maize Enhanced grain yield (ZMM28) DP202216 AA, FA, PX, VI, PA, CA, FeA, F, I, R, TrPI Isoline 16 (4 per each site) 8 2017 TI, Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Anderson et al. (2019)
Wheat Herbicide tolerance (glyphosate) MON71800 AA, FA, PX, VI, F, CA, FeA, MA, OA Bobwhite (T. aestiVum L) 25 (4 per each site) 7 1999/ 2000 TI, Mixed-model ANOVA across sites Obert et al. (2004)

Abbreviations: AA, amino acids; ANOVA, analysis of variance; CA, p-Coumaric acid; DA, dihydrosterculic acid; F, furtural; FA, fatty acids; FeA, ferulic acid; G, gossypol; I, inositol; IS, isoflavone; isoline, non-transgenic near-isogenic line; L, lectin; MA, malvalic acid; MI, minerals; Le, lectin; OA, oxalic acid; PA, phytic acid; PX, proximates (e.g., protein, fat, ash, fiber, moisture, carbohydrate); R, raffinose; S, stachyose; SA, sterculic acid; TI, tolerance interval; TrPI, trypsin inhibitor; VI, vitamins; MA, malonic acid; CA, carotenoids

J Plant Biotechnol 2020;47:261-72 https://doi.org/10.5010/JPB.2020.47.4.261
© 2020 J Plant Biotechnol