J Plant Biotechnol (2023) 50:127-136
Published online June 22, 2023
https://doi.org/10.5010/JPB.2023.50.016.127
© The Korean Society of Plant Biotechnology
Correspondence to : e-mail: srinanan@sith.itb.ac.id
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Water scarcity decreases the rate of photosynthesis and, consequently, the yield of banana plants (Musa spp). In this study, transcriptome analysis was performed to identify photosynthesis-related genes in banana plants and determine their expression profiles under water stress conditions. Banana plantlets were in vitro cultured on Murashige and Skoog agar medium with and without 10% polyethylene glycol and marked as BP10 and BK. Chlorophyll contents in the plant shoots were determined spectrophotometrically. Two cDNA libraries generated from BK and BP10 plantlets, respectively, were used as the reference for transcriptome data. Gene ontology (GO) enrichment analysis was performed using the Database for Annotation, Visualization, and Integrated Discovery (DAVID) and visualized using the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathway prediction. Morphological observations indicated that water deficiency caused chlorosis and reduced the shoot chlorophyll content of banana plantlets. GO enrichment identified 52 photosynthesis-related genes that were affected by water stress. KEGG visualization revealed the pathways related to the 52 photosynthesisrelated genes and their allocations in four GO terms. Four, 12, 15, and 21 genes were related to chlorophyll biosynthesis, the Calvin cycle, the photosynthetic electron transfer chain, and the light-harvesting complex, respectively. Differentially expressed gene (DEG) analysis using DESeq revealed that 45 genes were down-regulated, whereas seven genes were up-regulated. Four of the down-regulated genes were responsible for chlorophyll biosynthesis and appeared to cause the decrease in the banana leaf chlorophyll content. Among the annotated DEGs, MaPNDO, MaPSAL, and MaFEDA were selected and validated using quantitative real-time PCR.
Keywords Musa acuminata Colla, Photosynthesis, Transcriptome analysis, Water deficiency
Bananas (
Banana plants are known to suffer against water deficiency, although the drought tolerance response in banana is genotype-dependent (Nansamba et al. 2020; Ravi et al. 2013). There was a tendency that banana varieties with more ‘B’ genome are more tolerant to drought stress compare to the varieties with more ‘A’ genome (Wang et al. 2020). Studies were reported to discover effects of water stress to the disruption of physiological and biochemical processes in banana. Water deficiency is known to alter the normal condition of banana plants and causes the morphological and physiological changes. Many reports showed that to prevent water loss, tolerant banana plants made various morphological adjustments, such as leaf rolling, root lengthening, leaf size reduction, and leaf abscission. Changes also occurred in the cellular level, including changes in metabolic pathway directions, nutrient and ion uptakes, synthesis of new proteins or modulation of free radical generation (Surendar et al. 2013a; Wang et al. 2020).
To improve understanding about the molecular mechanism of banana plants to respond water stress, some studies have been accomplished using the next generation sequencing (NGS) technology. Transcriptomic analysis has become a reliable approach to unravel the integrated insight into abiotic stress tolerance mechanisms occurred in banana plants (Backiyarani et al. 2015; Hu et al. 2017). Transcriptomic analysis approach was able to discover enriched differentially expressed genes (DEGs) from cDNA libraries of the tolerant and sensitive banana cultivars that exposed to drought (Muthusamy et al. 2016). In drought-stressed banana, identified DEGs were mainly involved in important bioprocesses, such as lipid metabolism, carbohydrate degradation, protein modifications, alkaloid biosynthesis and other secondary metabolites. Major biological processes were known to be influenced by water deficiency, including photosynthesis, cellular respiration, responses to stress, and organ development.
Photosynthesis seems to be the most altered by drought and is very closely related to banana growth and fruit production (Surendar et al. 2013b). Impacts of water stress on photosynthesis have been studied based on molecular perspective in various plant species. Studies discovered disturbances of water deficit condition on photosynthesis and successfully identified some responsive genes involved in photosynthesis. Water scarcity has been known to decrease not only the photosynthesis rate, but also destruct the photosystem II, causing the decline of light capture capacity (Sasi et al. 2018). It was suggested that water- stress caused stomata closure, decreases stomata conductance and resulting in diverting electrons from the photosynthetic electron transport chain to molecular oxygen generating ROS at the end of photosystem I (Chen et al. 2020). It was reported that water shortage defected the protein structures of oxygen-evolving complex of PSII and PSI reaction centers (Dalal and Tripathy 2018). However, further studies are still needed to identify the potential genes for developing DNA based markers in the future. This study was aimed to identify photosynthetic related genes of water stressed banana plantlets and determining its expression profiles based on transcriptional analysis. A transcriptome dataset was generated from cDNA libraries of banana plantlets,
Plantlets of banana,
Shoot parts were detached from plantlets of the BK and BP10 after a four-week PEG treatment and prepared for chlorophyll extraction. As much as 0.1 g shoot tissues grinded and added with two ml 96% ethanol in 4-6 minutes until all the chlorophyll was dissolved (Wintermans and De Mots, 1965). Crude extracts were filtered with filter paper Whatman No.1. Chlorophyll contents were measured using a spectrophotometer (BioRad SmartSpec™Plus) at 649 nm and 665 nm wavelengths.
A transcriptome dataset obtained from previous experiments was used in this study as a reference data (Widiyanto et al. 2019, unpublished report) and as it was mentioned that the sequences of transcriptome data was registered at the NCBI BioProject database. Two cDNA libraries of banana (
To confirm the expressions of selected DEGs, an independent experiment was conducted to replicate a similar experiment with previous experiments when the cDNA libraries of transcriptome data were constructed. The total RNA samples were isolated from in vitro shoot cultures of the BK and BP10 banana cv Barangan Merah plantlets after four weeks of the PEG treatment. Three genes i.e.,
Table 1 . The primer sequences used for amplifying the selected (
Symbol | Gene name | Forward primer | Reverse primer | Amplification length (bases) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Actin ( | CTGACTGGCAGCAGGACATA | CCAAATCGTGCCTTTGAACT | 162 | |
Betatubulin ( | AGTCCGGAGCTTCAACCTTT | ACGCTGACGATGGAGAAGAC | 221 | |
2Fe-2S ferredoxin | TTGCCATCTCTCCCTGTCTT | GGCATTCGATCACCTTCTCT | 214 | |
photosystem I subunit l | GCATCTCACGAACACCATTG | GATGGGCTGAATCACTTGGT | 196 | |
Pyridine nucleotide-disulfide oxidoreductase | GCTTTCTCCAGCATCAAAGG | CCCATTCCTCCTTCGACATA | 216 |
Morphological observation indicated that plantlets of banana cv Barangan Merah regenerated from 10% PEG- exposed shoots (BP10) were turned pale and chlorosis after four weeks of culturing (Fig. 1). Leaves of plantlets were obviously experienced reduction of the normal growth and green coloration. In line with the morphological changes, chlorophyll determination implied that water deficiency caused a considerable reduction in total chlorophyll content (Fig. 2). Compare to that of the control plantlets (BK), total chlorophyll contents of the BP10 plantlets, as well as chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b were obviously decrease. It seemed that water deficiency experienced in banana plantlets inhibited its growth and chlorophyll biosynthesis, particularly in shoot parts.
The GO enrichment was completed using DAVID and identified 52 photosynthesis-related genes that were affected by water stress in BP10 plantlets Supplementary Table S.1. The 52 photosynthetic genes were distributed in four GO terms i.e., four genes in chlorophyll biosynthesis, twelve genes in Calvin cycle pathway, fifteen genes in photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC), and twenty- one genes in antenna light harvesting complex proteins (Table 2). The 52 identified genes were among the 100 annotated genes that either the most downregulated or upregulated in PEG treatments (PEG 2.5, PEG7, and PEG10) and listed in Supplementary Table S.2-S.3. The KEGG prediction pathway was applied to visualize the photosynthesis-related gene allocations.
Table 2 . The number of photosynthesis-related genes in water-stressed banana plantlets (categorized under four GO terms based on DAVID)
GO terminology | Numbers of genes |
---|---|
Biosynthesis of chlorophyll | 4 |
Calvin cycle | 12 |
Light-harvesting complex | 15 |
Photosynthetic electron transfer chain | 21 |
Total photosynthetic genes affected | 52 |
Based on transcriptomic analyses there were four genes in chlorophyll biosynthesis that affected by water stress (Table 3) and mapped into KEGG pathway (Supplementary Data Fig. S.1). The four genes are
Table 3 . List of the four genes related to porphyrin and chlorophyll metabolism whose expressions were altered under water stress (according to the KEGG prediction pathway)
Enzyme code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
1.3.1.33 | Ma11_p01810.1 | ||
Ma03_p14780.1 | |||
1.2.1.70 | Ma02_p00210.1 | ||
1.3.1.111 | Ma08_p24890.1 |
The Calvin cycle has three main phases, those are the carbon fixation, the reduction of carbon dioxide and regeneration of carbon dioxide acceptor phases. There were 12 identified genes in Calvin cycle that altered by water stress and were mapped into KEGG pathway. The alteration of 12 genes were illustrated in Supplementary Fig. S.2 and listed in Table 4. Based on KEGG pathway, there were seven genes up-regulated and five genes down- regulated. Water deficiency was down-regulated four genes of the 3-PGA biosynthesis in reduction phase and five genes in the RuBp regeneration phase. Water stress also interfered the expressions of transketolase (2.2.1.1) and aldolase superfamily protein (4.1.2.13) genes.
Table 4 . List of the twelve Calvin cycle-related genes whose expressions were altered by 10% PEG; seven genes were up-regulated and five genes were down-regulated
Enzyme code | Musa ID | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) |
---|---|---|---|
1.1.1.37 | Ma05_p03680.1 | ||
1.2.1.12 | Ma06_p01470.1 | ||
Ma06_p01470.1 | |||
2.6.1.2 | Ma11_p08770.1 | ||
4.1.2.13 | Ma06_p11050.1 | ||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
1.2.1.13 | Ma10_p12550.1 | ||
Ma11_p20650.1 | |||
2.2.1.1 | Ma03_p16840.1 | ||
2.7.1.19 | Ma05_p03450.1 | ||
2.7.9.1 | Ma03_p26110.1 |
Light harvesting is the first subprocess in light-dependent reactions occurs in antenna protein complexes located in photosystems on thylakoid membranes. There were 15 genes related to light harvesting complex and antenna proteins that affected by 10% PEG treatment which were mapped into KEGG pathway (Table 5). The KEGG map showed the allocations of 15 genes in the light harvesting complex (LHC) and antenna (Supplementary Fig. S.3). Identified genes consisted of 5 light harvesting complex-a (Lhca) genes located in photosystem I and 10 light harvesting complex-b (Lhcb) genes in photosystem II. It was indicated that photosystem-II was more sensitive and had more impacts by water stress than photosystem- I.
Table 5 . List of the 15 genes related to the antenna or light-harvesting complex (LHC) whose expressions were altered under water stress; according to the KEGG pathway, there were five light-harvesting complex-a (
KEGG Code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
Lhca1 | Ma02_p08270.1 | ||
Lhca2 | Ma06_p22130.1 | ||
Lhca3 | Ma03_p03930.1 | ||
Lhca4 | Ma02_p16740.1 | ||
Lhcb1 | Ma10_p15370.1 | ||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Ma10_p15370.1 | |||
Lhcb2 | Ma04_p39550.1 | ||
Ma04_p39550.1 | |||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Lhcb3 | Ma09_p21570.1 | ||
Lhcb4 | Ma08_p03640.1 | ||
Ma09_p02760.1 | |||
Lhcb5 | Ma06_p14120.2 | ||
Lhcb6 | Ma07_p20600.1 |
Genes related to photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC) that disrupted by water deficiency were mapped into KEGG pathway (Fig. 3) and listed in Supplementary Table S.1. The water stress condition was down-regulated a total of 21 genes in photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC) that might cause changes of excitation rate of electrons. These genes composed of a gene encodes enzyme 1.18.1.2
The confirmation of gene expressions showed that compared to the control plantlet (BK), the relative expressions of
Water deficiency is a critical factor for the growth of banana plants and causing substantial changes in its growth, morphological features and biochemistry reactions. Chlorosis is the condition of plant tissues, especially in shoots or leaves that lost their green color and turn pale as the result of lack of chlorophyll pigment (Surendar et al. 2013b). The chlorosis occurred in leaves of 10% PEG-exposed plantlets seemed to be correlated with the disruption in chlorophyll biosynthesis process. Chlorosis in banana leaves seemed to be occurred because of the deterioration of chlorophyll and other photosynthetic pigments (Vergeiner et al. 2013). Water shortage is also known to cause the disruption of ultrastructural feature of chloroplasts in teak (Galeano et al. 2019). The transcriptomic analysis in this study would be able to discover the reason.
Water stress in banana plantlets caused the decrease in chlorophyll content up to 52% (Fig. 2). A considerable reduction in total chlorophyll contents was also noticed in banana plants under water shortage condition in the field (Surendar et al. 2013b). Water stress decreased total chlorophyll content and declined yield of banana production. Chlorophyll biosynthesis is consisting of a biochemical reaction series and catalyzed by numerous enzymes as illustrated in Supplementary Fig. S.1. At least there are three distinct phases in chlorophyll biosynthesis. The first phase begins from glutamic acid metabolism pathway, including the heme biosynthesis pathway to synthesize protoporphyrin. Glutamyl-tRNA reductase family protein (1.2.1.70) enzyme encoded by the
As it was mentioned, the reference transcriptome data used in this study was obtained from previous experiments (Widiyanto et al. 2019, unpublished report). The transcriptome dataset was generated from four cDNA libraries of banana plantlets using Illumina MiSeqTM 2000 platform. In experiments, banana plantlets were in vitro regenerated from shoot-buds of
Correspondingly with the results of this study, KEGG mapping showed that in BP10 plantlets, water stress down-regulated the
The three main stages of Calvin cycle reactions are connected processes to each other. Changes in expression levels of the
In potato, dehydration was evidently reflected drought- responsive genes related to the alteration of the chloroplast structure (Chen et al. 2020). Water stress has been known to decrease the capacity of light capture, especially in C3 plants. It was indicated that photosystem II (PSII) was more disturbed by water stress than photosystem I (PSI), and it means that
Drought stress known to cause disruption of functions of structural and carrier proteins and also decrease the excitation rate of electrons at the reaction center of photosystems. Changes in expression levels of structural protein genes in the reaction center seemed not directly to cause loss of its functions (Wada et al. 2019). Our result showed that among genes related to photosystem-electron transfer chain there was one gene encodes enzyme 1.18.1.2 (
This study showed that the addition of 10% PEG induced water deficiency condition in banana plantlets and evidently affected not only chlorophyll biosynthesis, but also altered the biochemical reactions in Calvin cycle, disturbed the light-harvesting capacity and disrupted the electron transfer process in photosystem chains. Water deficiency made impacts to the expressions of 52 genes related to photosynthesis process of
SNW: Conceptualization, research supervision, writing of original draft manuscript; SS & SD: Methodology, formal analysis, research investigation; EM & HN: Visualization, review and editing of manuscript; FSI: Data curation, formal analysis; DSD: Critically review and editing the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest in the research.
This research was supported by: the Master Degree to Doctoral Scholarship Program for Excellence Undergraduate (PMDSU), Directorate General of Higher Education, Ministry of National Education, Indonesia (2019-2020); and the Program of Research, Community Service, and Innovation (2020-2021), School of Life Sciences and Technology, Institut Teknologi Bandung, Bandung, Indonesia.
J Plant Biotechnol 2023; 50(1): 127-136
Published online June 22, 2023 https://doi.org/10.5010/JPB.2023.50.016.127
Copyright © The Korean Society of Plant Biotechnology.
Sri Nanan Widiyanto ・Syahril Sulaiman ・Simon Duve ・Erly Marwani ・Husna Nugrahapraja ・Diky Setya Diningrat
School of Life Sciences and Technology, Institut Teknologi Bandung, Bandung 40132, Indonesia
School of Life Sciences and Technology, Institut Teknologi Bandung, Bandung 40132, Indonesia
Department of Biology, Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences, Medan State University, Medan 20221, Indonesia
Correspondence to:e-mail: srinanan@sith.itb.ac.id
This is an Open-Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0) which permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Water scarcity decreases the rate of photosynthesis and, consequently, the yield of banana plants (Musa spp). In this study, transcriptome analysis was performed to identify photosynthesis-related genes in banana plants and determine their expression profiles under water stress conditions. Banana plantlets were in vitro cultured on Murashige and Skoog agar medium with and without 10% polyethylene glycol and marked as BP10 and BK. Chlorophyll contents in the plant shoots were determined spectrophotometrically. Two cDNA libraries generated from BK and BP10 plantlets, respectively, were used as the reference for transcriptome data. Gene ontology (GO) enrichment analysis was performed using the Database for Annotation, Visualization, and Integrated Discovery (DAVID) and visualized using the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) pathway prediction. Morphological observations indicated that water deficiency caused chlorosis and reduced the shoot chlorophyll content of banana plantlets. GO enrichment identified 52 photosynthesis-related genes that were affected by water stress. KEGG visualization revealed the pathways related to the 52 photosynthesisrelated genes and their allocations in four GO terms. Four, 12, 15, and 21 genes were related to chlorophyll biosynthesis, the Calvin cycle, the photosynthetic electron transfer chain, and the light-harvesting complex, respectively. Differentially expressed gene (DEG) analysis using DESeq revealed that 45 genes were down-regulated, whereas seven genes were up-regulated. Four of the down-regulated genes were responsible for chlorophyll biosynthesis and appeared to cause the decrease in the banana leaf chlorophyll content. Among the annotated DEGs, MaPNDO, MaPSAL, and MaFEDA were selected and validated using quantitative real-time PCR.
Keywords: Musa acuminata Colla, Photosynthesis, Transcriptome analysis, Water deficiency
Bananas (
Banana plants are known to suffer against water deficiency, although the drought tolerance response in banana is genotype-dependent (Nansamba et al. 2020; Ravi et al. 2013). There was a tendency that banana varieties with more ‘B’ genome are more tolerant to drought stress compare to the varieties with more ‘A’ genome (Wang et al. 2020). Studies were reported to discover effects of water stress to the disruption of physiological and biochemical processes in banana. Water deficiency is known to alter the normal condition of banana plants and causes the morphological and physiological changes. Many reports showed that to prevent water loss, tolerant banana plants made various morphological adjustments, such as leaf rolling, root lengthening, leaf size reduction, and leaf abscission. Changes also occurred in the cellular level, including changes in metabolic pathway directions, nutrient and ion uptakes, synthesis of new proteins or modulation of free radical generation (Surendar et al. 2013a; Wang et al. 2020).
To improve understanding about the molecular mechanism of banana plants to respond water stress, some studies have been accomplished using the next generation sequencing (NGS) technology. Transcriptomic analysis has become a reliable approach to unravel the integrated insight into abiotic stress tolerance mechanisms occurred in banana plants (Backiyarani et al. 2015; Hu et al. 2017). Transcriptomic analysis approach was able to discover enriched differentially expressed genes (DEGs) from cDNA libraries of the tolerant and sensitive banana cultivars that exposed to drought (Muthusamy et al. 2016). In drought-stressed banana, identified DEGs were mainly involved in important bioprocesses, such as lipid metabolism, carbohydrate degradation, protein modifications, alkaloid biosynthesis and other secondary metabolites. Major biological processes were known to be influenced by water deficiency, including photosynthesis, cellular respiration, responses to stress, and organ development.
Photosynthesis seems to be the most altered by drought and is very closely related to banana growth and fruit production (Surendar et al. 2013b). Impacts of water stress on photosynthesis have been studied based on molecular perspective in various plant species. Studies discovered disturbances of water deficit condition on photosynthesis and successfully identified some responsive genes involved in photosynthesis. Water scarcity has been known to decrease not only the photosynthesis rate, but also destruct the photosystem II, causing the decline of light capture capacity (Sasi et al. 2018). It was suggested that water- stress caused stomata closure, decreases stomata conductance and resulting in diverting electrons from the photosynthetic electron transport chain to molecular oxygen generating ROS at the end of photosystem I (Chen et al. 2020). It was reported that water shortage defected the protein structures of oxygen-evolving complex of PSII and PSI reaction centers (Dalal and Tripathy 2018). However, further studies are still needed to identify the potential genes for developing DNA based markers in the future. This study was aimed to identify photosynthetic related genes of water stressed banana plantlets and determining its expression profiles based on transcriptional analysis. A transcriptome dataset was generated from cDNA libraries of banana plantlets,
Plantlets of banana,
Shoot parts were detached from plantlets of the BK and BP10 after a four-week PEG treatment and prepared for chlorophyll extraction. As much as 0.1 g shoot tissues grinded and added with two ml 96% ethanol in 4-6 minutes until all the chlorophyll was dissolved (Wintermans and De Mots, 1965). Crude extracts were filtered with filter paper Whatman No.1. Chlorophyll contents were measured using a spectrophotometer (BioRad SmartSpec™Plus) at 649 nm and 665 nm wavelengths.
A transcriptome dataset obtained from previous experiments was used in this study as a reference data (Widiyanto et al. 2019, unpublished report) and as it was mentioned that the sequences of transcriptome data was registered at the NCBI BioProject database. Two cDNA libraries of banana (
To confirm the expressions of selected DEGs, an independent experiment was conducted to replicate a similar experiment with previous experiments when the cDNA libraries of transcriptome data were constructed. The total RNA samples were isolated from in vitro shoot cultures of the BK and BP10 banana cv Barangan Merah plantlets after four weeks of the PEG treatment. Three genes i.e.,
Table 1 . The primer sequences used for amplifying the selected (
Symbol | Gene name | Forward primer | Reverse primer | Amplification length (bases) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Actin ( | CTGACTGGCAGCAGGACATA | CCAAATCGTGCCTTTGAACT | 162 | |
Betatubulin ( | AGTCCGGAGCTTCAACCTTT | ACGCTGACGATGGAGAAGAC | 221 | |
2Fe-2S ferredoxin | TTGCCATCTCTCCCTGTCTT | GGCATTCGATCACCTTCTCT | 214 | |
photosystem I subunit l | GCATCTCACGAACACCATTG | GATGGGCTGAATCACTTGGT | 196 | |
Pyridine nucleotide-disulfide oxidoreductase | GCTTTCTCCAGCATCAAAGG | CCCATTCCTCCTTCGACATA | 216 |
Morphological observation indicated that plantlets of banana cv Barangan Merah regenerated from 10% PEG- exposed shoots (BP10) were turned pale and chlorosis after four weeks of culturing (Fig. 1). Leaves of plantlets were obviously experienced reduction of the normal growth and green coloration. In line with the morphological changes, chlorophyll determination implied that water deficiency caused a considerable reduction in total chlorophyll content (Fig. 2). Compare to that of the control plantlets (BK), total chlorophyll contents of the BP10 plantlets, as well as chlorophyll a and chlorophyll b were obviously decrease. It seemed that water deficiency experienced in banana plantlets inhibited its growth and chlorophyll biosynthesis, particularly in shoot parts.
The GO enrichment was completed using DAVID and identified 52 photosynthesis-related genes that were affected by water stress in BP10 plantlets Supplementary Table S.1. The 52 photosynthetic genes were distributed in four GO terms i.e., four genes in chlorophyll biosynthesis, twelve genes in Calvin cycle pathway, fifteen genes in photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC), and twenty- one genes in antenna light harvesting complex proteins (Table 2). The 52 identified genes were among the 100 annotated genes that either the most downregulated or upregulated in PEG treatments (PEG 2.5, PEG7, and PEG10) and listed in Supplementary Table S.2-S.3. The KEGG prediction pathway was applied to visualize the photosynthesis-related gene allocations.
Table 2 . The number of photosynthesis-related genes in water-stressed banana plantlets (categorized under four GO terms based on DAVID).
GO terminology | Numbers of genes |
---|---|
Biosynthesis of chlorophyll | 4 |
Calvin cycle | 12 |
Light-harvesting complex | 15 |
Photosynthetic electron transfer chain | 21 |
Total photosynthetic genes affected | 52 |
Based on transcriptomic analyses there were four genes in chlorophyll biosynthesis that affected by water stress (Table 3) and mapped into KEGG pathway (Supplementary Data Fig. S.1). The four genes are
Table 3 . List of the four genes related to porphyrin and chlorophyll metabolism whose expressions were altered under water stress (according to the KEGG prediction pathway).
Enzyme code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
1.3.1.33 | Ma11_p01810.1 | ||
Ma03_p14780.1 | |||
1.2.1.70 | Ma02_p00210.1 | ||
1.3.1.111 | Ma08_p24890.1 |
The Calvin cycle has three main phases, those are the carbon fixation, the reduction of carbon dioxide and regeneration of carbon dioxide acceptor phases. There were 12 identified genes in Calvin cycle that altered by water stress and were mapped into KEGG pathway. The alteration of 12 genes were illustrated in Supplementary Fig. S.2 and listed in Table 4. Based on KEGG pathway, there were seven genes up-regulated and five genes down- regulated. Water deficiency was down-regulated four genes of the 3-PGA biosynthesis in reduction phase and five genes in the RuBp regeneration phase. Water stress also interfered the expressions of transketolase (2.2.1.1) and aldolase superfamily protein (4.1.2.13) genes.
Table 4 . List of the twelve Calvin cycle-related genes whose expressions were altered by 10% PEG; seven genes were up-regulated and five genes were down-regulated.
Enzyme code | Musa ID | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) |
---|---|---|---|
1.1.1.37 | Ma05_p03680.1 | ||
1.2.1.12 | Ma06_p01470.1 | ||
Ma06_p01470.1 | |||
2.6.1.2 | Ma11_p08770.1 | ||
4.1.2.13 | Ma06_p11050.1 | ||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
1.2.1.13 | Ma10_p12550.1 | ||
Ma11_p20650.1 | |||
2.2.1.1 | Ma03_p16840.1 | ||
2.7.1.19 | Ma05_p03450.1 | ||
2.7.9.1 | Ma03_p26110.1 |
Light harvesting is the first subprocess in light-dependent reactions occurs in antenna protein complexes located in photosystems on thylakoid membranes. There were 15 genes related to light harvesting complex and antenna proteins that affected by 10% PEG treatment which were mapped into KEGG pathway (Table 5). The KEGG map showed the allocations of 15 genes in the light harvesting complex (LHC) and antenna (Supplementary Fig. S.3). Identified genes consisted of 5 light harvesting complex-a (Lhca) genes located in photosystem I and 10 light harvesting complex-b (Lhcb) genes in photosystem II. It was indicated that photosystem-II was more sensitive and had more impacts by water stress than photosystem- I.
Table 5 . List of the 15 genes related to the antenna or light-harvesting complex (LHC) whose expressions were altered under water stress; according to the KEGG pathway, there were five light-harvesting complex-a (
KEGG Code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
Lhca1 | Ma02_p08270.1 | ||
Lhca2 | Ma06_p22130.1 | ||
Lhca3 | Ma03_p03930.1 | ||
Lhca4 | Ma02_p16740.1 | ||
Lhcb1 | Ma10_p15370.1 | ||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Ma10_p15370.1 | |||
Lhcb2 | Ma04_p39550.1 | ||
Ma04_p39550.1 | |||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Lhcb3 | Ma09_p21570.1 | ||
Lhcb4 | Ma08_p03640.1 | ||
Ma09_p02760.1 | |||
Lhcb5 | Ma06_p14120.2 | ||
Lhcb6 | Ma07_p20600.1 |
Genes related to photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC) that disrupted by water deficiency were mapped into KEGG pathway (Fig. 3) and listed in Supplementary Table S.1. The water stress condition was down-regulated a total of 21 genes in photosystem-electron transfer chain (PETC) that might cause changes of excitation rate of electrons. These genes composed of a gene encodes enzyme 1.18.1.2
The confirmation of gene expressions showed that compared to the control plantlet (BK), the relative expressions of
Water deficiency is a critical factor for the growth of banana plants and causing substantial changes in its growth, morphological features and biochemistry reactions. Chlorosis is the condition of plant tissues, especially in shoots or leaves that lost their green color and turn pale as the result of lack of chlorophyll pigment (Surendar et al. 2013b). The chlorosis occurred in leaves of 10% PEG-exposed plantlets seemed to be correlated with the disruption in chlorophyll biosynthesis process. Chlorosis in banana leaves seemed to be occurred because of the deterioration of chlorophyll and other photosynthetic pigments (Vergeiner et al. 2013). Water shortage is also known to cause the disruption of ultrastructural feature of chloroplasts in teak (Galeano et al. 2019). The transcriptomic analysis in this study would be able to discover the reason.
Water stress in banana plantlets caused the decrease in chlorophyll content up to 52% (Fig. 2). A considerable reduction in total chlorophyll contents was also noticed in banana plants under water shortage condition in the field (Surendar et al. 2013b). Water stress decreased total chlorophyll content and declined yield of banana production. Chlorophyll biosynthesis is consisting of a biochemical reaction series and catalyzed by numerous enzymes as illustrated in Supplementary Fig. S.1. At least there are three distinct phases in chlorophyll biosynthesis. The first phase begins from glutamic acid metabolism pathway, including the heme biosynthesis pathway to synthesize protoporphyrin. Glutamyl-tRNA reductase family protein (1.2.1.70) enzyme encoded by the
As it was mentioned, the reference transcriptome data used in this study was obtained from previous experiments (Widiyanto et al. 2019, unpublished report). The transcriptome dataset was generated from four cDNA libraries of banana plantlets using Illumina MiSeqTM 2000 platform. In experiments, banana plantlets were in vitro regenerated from shoot-buds of
Correspondingly with the results of this study, KEGG mapping showed that in BP10 plantlets, water stress down-regulated the
The three main stages of Calvin cycle reactions are connected processes to each other. Changes in expression levels of the
In potato, dehydration was evidently reflected drought- responsive genes related to the alteration of the chloroplast structure (Chen et al. 2020). Water stress has been known to decrease the capacity of light capture, especially in C3 plants. It was indicated that photosystem II (PSII) was more disturbed by water stress than photosystem I (PSI), and it means that
Drought stress known to cause disruption of functions of structural and carrier proteins and also decrease the excitation rate of electrons at the reaction center of photosystems. Changes in expression levels of structural protein genes in the reaction center seemed not directly to cause loss of its functions (Wada et al. 2019). Our result showed that among genes related to photosystem-electron transfer chain there was one gene encodes enzyme 1.18.1.2 (
This study showed that the addition of 10% PEG induced water deficiency condition in banana plantlets and evidently affected not only chlorophyll biosynthesis, but also altered the biochemical reactions in Calvin cycle, disturbed the light-harvesting capacity and disrupted the electron transfer process in photosystem chains. Water deficiency made impacts to the expressions of 52 genes related to photosynthesis process of
SNW: Conceptualization, research supervision, writing of original draft manuscript; SS & SD: Methodology, formal analysis, research investigation; EM & HN: Visualization, review and editing of manuscript; FSI: Data curation, formal analysis; DSD: Critically review and editing the manuscript. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest in the research.
This research was supported by: the Master Degree to Doctoral Scholarship Program for Excellence Undergraduate (PMDSU), Directorate General of Higher Education, Ministry of National Education, Indonesia (2019-2020); and the Program of Research, Community Service, and Innovation (2020-2021), School of Life Sciences and Technology, Institut Teknologi Bandung, Bandung, Indonesia.
Table 1 . The primer sequences used for amplifying the selected (
Symbol | Gene name | Forward primer | Reverse primer | Amplification length (bases) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Actin ( | CTGACTGGCAGCAGGACATA | CCAAATCGTGCCTTTGAACT | 162 | |
Betatubulin ( | AGTCCGGAGCTTCAACCTTT | ACGCTGACGATGGAGAAGAC | 221 | |
2Fe-2S ferredoxin | TTGCCATCTCTCCCTGTCTT | GGCATTCGATCACCTTCTCT | 214 | |
photosystem I subunit l | GCATCTCACGAACACCATTG | GATGGGCTGAATCACTTGGT | 196 | |
Pyridine nucleotide-disulfide oxidoreductase | GCTTTCTCCAGCATCAAAGG | CCCATTCCTCCTTCGACATA | 216 |
Table 2 . The number of photosynthesis-related genes in water-stressed banana plantlets (categorized under four GO terms based on DAVID).
GO terminology | Numbers of genes |
---|---|
Biosynthesis of chlorophyll | 4 |
Calvin cycle | 12 |
Light-harvesting complex | 15 |
Photosynthetic electron transfer chain | 21 |
Total photosynthetic genes affected | 52 |
Table 3 . List of the four genes related to porphyrin and chlorophyll metabolism whose expressions were altered under water stress (according to the KEGG prediction pathway).
Enzyme code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
1.3.1.33 | Ma11_p01810.1 | ||
Ma03_p14780.1 | |||
1.2.1.70 | Ma02_p00210.1 | ||
1.3.1.111 | Ma08_p24890.1 |
Table 4 . List of the twelve Calvin cycle-related genes whose expressions were altered by 10% PEG; seven genes were up-regulated and five genes were down-regulated.
Enzyme code | Musa ID | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) |
---|---|---|---|
1.1.1.37 | Ma05_p03680.1 | ||
1.2.1.12 | Ma06_p01470.1 | ||
Ma06_p01470.1 | |||
2.6.1.2 | Ma11_p08770.1 | ||
4.1.2.13 | Ma06_p11050.1 | ||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
Ma05_p27790.1 | |||
1.2.1.13 | Ma10_p12550.1 | ||
Ma11_p20650.1 | |||
2.2.1.1 | Ma03_p16840.1 | ||
2.7.1.19 | Ma05_p03450.1 | ||
2.7.9.1 | Ma03_p26110.1 |
Table 5 . List of the 15 genes related to the antenna or light-harvesting complex (LHC) whose expressions were altered under water stress; according to the KEGG pathway, there were five light-harvesting complex-a (
KEGG Code | Symbol | Gene name (encoded protein) | |
---|---|---|---|
Lhca1 | Ma02_p08270.1 | ||
Lhca2 | Ma06_p22130.1 | ||
Lhca3 | Ma03_p03930.1 | ||
Lhca4 | Ma02_p16740.1 | ||
Lhcb1 | Ma10_p15370.1 | ||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Ma10_p15370.1 | |||
Lhcb2 | Ma04_p39550.1 | ||
Ma04_p39550.1 | |||
Ma02_p11170.1 | |||
Lhcb3 | Ma09_p21570.1 | ||
Lhcb4 | Ma08_p03640.1 | ||
Ma09_p02760.1 | |||
Lhcb5 | Ma06_p14120.2 | ||
Lhcb6 | Ma07_p20600.1 |
Nuri Park, Hye-Jeong Ha, Saminathan Subburaj, Seo-Hee Choi, Yongsam Jeon, Yong-Tae Jin, Luhua Tu, Shipra Kumari, and Geung-Joo Lee
J Plant Biotechnol 2016; 43(3): 359-366
Journal of
Plant Biotechnology